Homepage / Uncategorized / Eminence Based Medicine
FDIC 2017 – Structural Response to Aviation Incidents: Engine Company Operations I Got Lost Going to a Call – So I made sure everyone knew about it Crossover Podcast Ep 102 Mrs Happy Medic and Mike the Cop Arby’s Roast Beef Ad angers EMTs, not sure why Strippers and Cocaine watch – 2017 Seizures! Seizures Everywhere! Nothing is certain except death and taxes. I can help you with both What to do when the powers that be – just can’t. Episode 99 the Crossover Ep 98 – Off Duty and Fancy Free NO is Never Easy to Hear Ohio Cop vs Ambulance Crew Member on Video – Crossover Show Investigates! An MCI With Wings: Aviation Incidents EMS Today 2017 First in Ambulance MCI at EMS Today 2017 Crossover Show Learns How to Take a Joke To Haul or Not to Haul – Should the Complexity of a Refusal Influence Transport? Crossover Show – Ep 91 – ACLU cameras Tip of the Helmet – Bj’s Brewhouse the Crossover Show – Episode Eighty Eight Eminence Based Medicine If You Don’t Give Him Insulin He’s Going to Die Lost Cause Strikes Again the Crossover Podcast – Ep 85 – Florida Cry Baby “I Can’t Breathe!” you keep using those words… the Crossover Show – 84 – TN Bus Crash Happy 150th Anniversary San Francisco Fire Department! Thank You For Your Service? A Complete Secondary Assessment the Crossover Episode 81 – Let’s Talk Politics! Aircraft skids off runway, rescue task force ill equipped Crossover Show – Ep 79 – Do we need so much active shooter training? How to Ignore Everyone in the Room: Be an Intern Your Meme is Bad and You’re Not One of Us Anymore Goodbye tarps, I never loved you The Crossover Episode 76 – Flashback to the Beginning You found me how? Less CSI, More Columbo EMS Festival Standby – You can’t just park a car there the Crossover Show Ep 72 – Florida EMT photo game A&O vs able to make decisions Kilted to Kick Cancer Cops vs Firemen Writer calls for Medics to risk more in shootings, misses the target What’s with the French? the Crossover – Ep 69 – Twelve Ninety Désolé the Crossover Show – Ep 67 – Traffic Stops and Profiling Actually, Officer, No. It Really isn’t that hard to try When Patients Don’t Play by the Old Rules Letters in the File – Oklaloosa Selfies the Crossover Podcast – Ep 64 – Turning Passion into Retirement Why Pokemon GO is so much like EMS Us Against Us Apathy is worse than absence So Now I’m Back! Changes are a-comin’ The Sounds of Silence I know that feel, Bro TCS – Ep 59 – SHOOT HIM! CISD with OK GO part VI the Crossover – Ep 56 – Rooms for Shooting the Ballad of Big Dave the Crossover Episode 55 – Text me Bro Why vs How and Book vs Street A Mother’s Day Crossover Show Dear Valencia County Fire Chiefs Dear Random Township Fire Department at FDIC the Crossover Show – ep 50 – Revenge of the Vine Stars Strippers and Cocaine need your help Educational Standards in EMS Engine Company First Strike MCI – FDIC 2016 the Crossover Show – Ep 48 – What’s in your feed? Washing the Chief’s Car What Should I Do With This Knife? – The Crossover Ep 46 Firefighter Jokes Medical/Legal Advice, Google Style the Crossover Show – Episode 45 – Cop Vines and the Cajun John Wayne You Make the Call ebook Now Available To the Intern Who Froze the Crossover Show – Episode 44 – Day of Remembrance New at Uniform Stories – Raising Revenue BLS Fire Officer or Paramedic – Who Makes Scene Decisions? the Crossover Show – Episode 43 – Viewer Questions Why Budgeting Matters – Our Plumbing Nightmare the Crossover Show – Episode 42 – Protesting a Rally with a March DC FEMS MD Quits, calls FD Leadership “Toxic” the Crossover Show – Episode 41 – America Ball The more things change… Hey Board of Supervisors, You’re Remembering the Wrong People the Crossover Show – Episode 38 – How not to Get Tazered the Crossover Show – Episode 37 – What Makes a Good Chief? Johnny and Roy lied to me – I write receipts Defining System Abuse – A Response to Ambulance Chaser the Crossover Show – Episode 36 – Perception vs Reality Good Morning America skims over Fatigue in EMS Police-24,336,756 EMS-4 EMS Bike Program from the ground up Become a Patron of the Arts – Support the Crossover Show! Engine Company First Strike MCI in San Bernardino Video Shows Woman Banging on Ambulance Accusing Them of Organ Harvesting


Eminence Based Medicine

Eminence Based Medicine is a phrase I heard on one of my favorite podcasts, Freakonomics, which was talking about “Bad Medicine” and the fact that the more we actually investigate what we’re doing, the more we find out we don’t know what we’re doing.

The episode starts by investigating 98.6 and the methods used to determine the “normal temperature” of humans.  Fascinating story short, the methods were flawed, the tools were flawed and the conclusions shoddy at best.  Have a listen for the full story.

As they point out in the 3 part series, we think of medicine as being highly scientific but, it turns out, we have only really embraced evidence based treatments in the last 20 years.  Within my service time.


That should frighten everyone.


Dr Vinay Prasad, a Hematologist-Oncologist and Assistant Professor of Medicine at Oregon Health University was a guest on the show and uttered the phrase that titles this post.  He was comparing evidence based medicine to previous practice, demonstrating that until recently we went with what the oldest, most experienced person in the room did and assumed that was the thing to do.  Eminence Based Medicine.


We in EMS LOVE our war stories, our observations passed along as fact and the EMS Anchors who spin yarns about the old days when things used to work, long before all this new fangled BS came along.

EMS is an expert in Eminence Based Medicine.

How else can you explain most of the “treatments” we apply to patients, specifically trauma and cardiac arrest, arguably the places we can make the biggest difference in patient condition?  Or can we?  Have we become so entrenched in a skill set that we have forgotten to review what we do for effectiveness?

Or do we know, deep down inside, that most of what we do has no basis in fact?


If data was properly collected and reviewed that showed that cardiac arrest patients had better outcomes if a peanut butter sandwich to the chest was just as effective as a mechanical CPR machine, how quick would EMS implement it?

If no evidence existed for said intervention, say if it only mirrored the outcomes for patients without it, would we still be so quick to make sure it is on every rig?

Do you think I’m still talking about the peanut butter sandwich?


Evidence Based Medicine will drastically change the EMS landscape.  Yes, skills will be decreased in favor of more specific interventions and application of technique.  Some of our brothers and sisters will cling to their laryngoscopes so tightly, citing bad studies and flawed data, instead of hitting the airway lab to maybe get better.  Cardiac arrests filled with drugs and drips and cooling and tubes may be reduced to BLS calls, not because the ALS is hurting, but because we’ll learn that most cardiac arrests did not start in the heart and can not be addressed with our narrow arsenal of cardio toxins.


“We’ve always done it that way” are he 6 most dangerous words in EMS and yet are the basis for most of what we do.  Don’t believe me?  Look at the push back against eliminating long spine boards, the sudden reversal on pre-hospital cooling (although the data has always been the same) and the fact we are still transporting patients in cardiac arrest to the hospital.

If we demand evidence for new treatments we must also demand evidence for existing treatments.  All of them.  Perhaps it is not the poorly educated EMS masses we complain about that are leading to poor outcomes but instead our blind devotion to the comfortable, time honored tradition of looking to the oldest, most experienced person in the room and asking them what to do.


Demand Evidence.

Reject Eminence.

Otherwise, what are we even doing anymore?

Related posts:

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *